Your browser does not support the PubReader view.
Go to this page to see a list of supporting browsers.
The Korean Association for the Study of English Language and Linguistics
[ Article ]
Korea Journal of English Language and Linguistics - Vol. 18, No. 3, pp.349-380
ISSN: 1598-1398 (Print) 2586-7474 (Online)
Print publication date 30 Sep 2018
Received 10 May 2018 Revised 10 Sep 2018 Accepted 18 Sep 2018
DOI: https://doi.org/10.15738/kjell.18.3.201809.349

글로벌 인재와 영어능력에 관한 담론적 실천과 신자유주의 주체성의 이해

신동일
교수, 중앙대학교 영어영문학과 서울시 동작구 흑석동 221 shin@cau.ac.kr
Understanding discoursive practice and neoliberal subjectivities of global talents and their English language competence
Shin, Dongil

Correspondence to: 신동일 교수, 중앙대학교 영어영문학과 서울시 동작구 흑석동 221 E-mail: shin@cau.ac.kr

Abstract

Shin, Dongil. (2018). Understanding discoursive practice and neoliberal subjectivities of global talents and their English language competence. Journal of the English Language and Linguistics 18(3), 349-380. The primary purpose of this study is to understand the discursive practice and neoliberal subjectivities of global talents (human resource) and their English language competence represented in the Korean newspaper reportages. Through Foucault’s (2012, 2015) governmentality and subjectivities, this study illustrated how the rationalization and legitimation of global talent as a neoliberal subject were inextricably related to process of neoliberal knowledge and power production. Drawing on Dean’s (2010) analytics of governmentality, this article traced the genealogy of the global talent discourse in Chosunilbo, Dongailbo, and Kyunghyang Shinmun newspapers by analyzing all the article texts between 1993 and 2016. The genealogy demonstrated the inextricable connection between market-driven rationalities, technologies of control and the (re)construction of global talents under neoliberal governmentality. Since early 2000s, it has been pointed that the complicated discursive practice on competition, neoliberal enterpreneurship, multiculturalism, transnationalism, and global citizenship was extended to reformulate the slippery subjectivities of global talents.

Keywords:

global talent, global human resource, discourse analysis, Foucault, neoliberalism, governmentality, subjectivities

Acknowledgments

이 논문 또는 저서는 2016년 대한민국 교육부와 한국연구재단의 지원을 받아 수행된 연구임 (NRF-2016S1A5A2A01024156)

References

  • 강진웅(Kang, J.). 2014. 푸코의 권력과 주체: 통치성과 윤리적 주체(Foucault’s power and subject: Governmentality and ethical subject). 《사회와 역사》(Korean Social History Association) 103, 401-423.
  • 김가현⋅신동일(Kim, K. and D. Shin). 2016. 글로벌 인재와 영어 능력에 관한 비판적 담 론분석(A critical discourse analysis on global talents and their English competence). 《사회언어학》(The Sociolinguistic Journal of Korea) 24-3, 249-280.
  • 김상운(Kim, S.). (역). 2015. 『사회를 보호해야 한다: 콜레주드프랑스 강의 1975~76년』 (M. Foucault의 Il faut defendre la societe: cours au College de France, 1975-1976). 서울: 난장.
  • 김용(Kim, Y.). (역). 2015. 『신자유주의 교육정책, 계보와 그 너머: 세계화, 시민성, 민주 주의』(M. Olssen, J. Codd, A. O’Neill의 Education Policy: Globalization, Citizenship and Democracy). 서울: 학이시습.
  • 김은준(Kim, E.-J.). 2012. 『신자유주의 시대 교육 담론과 주체 형성: 한국의 대학입학사 정관제를 중심으로』(Educational Discourses and Formation of Subjectivity in the Era of Neoliberalism: The Case Study of the Admission Officer Policy in Korea). 충남대학교 출판문화원.
  • 김종국(Kim, J.-K.). (역). 2003. 『맥도날드 그리고 맥도날드화: 유토피아인가, 디스토피아인가?』(G. Ritzer의 The McDonaldization of Society). 서울: 시유시.
  • 김주환(Kim, J.). 2017. 『포획된 저항: 신자유주의와 통치성, 헤게모니 그리고 사회적 기업의 정치학』(Resistance Captured: Neoliberalism, Govermentality, Hegemony, and Politics of Social Enterprise). 서울: 이매진.
  • 김지홍(Kim, J.-H.). (역). 2012. 『담화분석방법: 사회조사연구를 위한 텍스트분석』(N. Fairclough의 Analysing Discourse: Textual Analysis for Social Research). 서울: 경진.
  • 김지홍(Kim, J.-H.). (역). 2017. 『담화와 사회변화』(N. Fairclough의 Discourse & Social Change). 서울: 경진.
  • 노형일⋅양은경(Roh, H. and E. Yang). 2017. 비폭력 저항 주체의 형성: 박근혜 대통령 탄핵 촛불집회에 대한 통치분석(The formation of nonviolent subjects: Analysing regimes of government on 2016 candlelight protest against President Park). 《한국방송학보》(Korean Journal of Broadcasting and Telecommunication Studies) 31-3, 5-41.
  • 도승연(Dho, S.-Y.). 2014. 푸코의 통치성 관점에서 바라본 신빈곤 속의 여성의 삶: 21세기 한국 농업이주여성 노동자의 경우에 관하여(The lives of women in ‘new poverty’ from the Foucault's perspective on governmentality: on the case of the migrant women-workers in South Korean agriculture business in 21th century.). 《한국여성철학》(Korean Feminist Philosophy) 22, 5-33.
  • 도승연(Dho, S.-Y). 2015. 푸코의 통치성 관점에서 본 로컬 푸드의 한계와 한국적 적용의 현실(The limitation of local food in terms of Foucault`s “Governmentailty” and its adaptation in Korean reality). 《한민족문화연구》(The Review of Korean Cultural Studies) 52, 429-457.
  • 박소연⋅송영수(Park, S. and Y. Song). 2008. 기업의 글로벌 인재 육성(HDR)을 위한 글로벌 비즈니스 역량 분석: 기업과 대학생의 인식을 중심으로(The study for global business competency model to develop the talent in the large enterprises in Korea). 《인력개발연구》(The Korean Journal for Human Resource Development) 10-3, 65-85.
  • 박수현⋅신동일(Park, S. and D. Shin). 2016. 영어능력 인증에 대한 비판적 담론분석: 국내 대학의 영어졸업인증제도를 중심으로(A critical discourse analysis of Korean newspaper reportage of Korean universities’ graduation accreditation system for English proficiency certification).《응용언어학》(Korean Journal of Applied Linguistics) 32-4, 175-208.
  • 박수현⋅신동일(Park, S. and D. Shin). 2018. 영어졸업인증제도의 역사성에 대한 비판적 담론분석: 푸코의 통치성에 대한 논의를 중심으로(Understanding the historical flow of media discourse on the graduation accreditation system for an English proficiency certification: on the basis of Michel Foucault's governmentality).《응용언어학》(Korean Journal of Applied Linguistics) 34-1, 29-58.
  • 박혜경(Park, H.). 2010. 신자유주의적 주부 주체화 담론의 계보학: 신문기사를 중심으로 (Subjectification of neo-liberal housewife: Discourse analysis of daily newspaper articles). 《한국여성학》(Journal of Korean Women’s Studies) 26-2, 127-158.
  • 서덕희(Seo, D.). 2003. ‘교실붕괴’ 기사에 대한 비판적 담론분석: 조선일보를 중심으로(A critical discourse analysis on the "Classroom Collapse" reports: Focusing on the Chosun Ilbo’s). 《교육인류학 연구》(Anthropology of Education) 6-2, 55-89.
  • 서덕희(Seo, D.). 2006. ‘교실붕괴’ 이후 신자유주의 교육담론의 형성과 그 저항: 홈스쿨링에 대한 담론분석을 중심으로(The formation of neo-liberal discourse on education after "Classroom Collapse", and resistance to it : A critical discourse analysis on homeschooling reports in South Korea). 《교육사회학 연구》(Korean Journal of Sociology of Education) 16-1, 77-105.
  • 서동진(Seo, D). 2009. 『자유의 의지 자기계발의 의지: 신자유주의 한국사회에서 자기계발하는 주체의 탄생』(The Will of Freedom and Self-development) 서울: 돌베개.
  • 서동진(Seo, D.). 2014. 신자유주의 통치성과 그 음산한 배면 (Neoliberal governmentality and the rear gloomy) 《문화과학》(Culture Science) 77, 21-34.
  • 신동일(Shin, D.). 2013. 언어교육의 후기-현대성에 관한 인문학적 고찰: 맥커뮤니케이션, 자아정체성, 그리고 생태주의 관점에서부터(Understanding the late-modernity of language learning: from the views of McCommunication, self-identities, and ecology).《영어영문학》(The Journal of English Language and Literature) 59-1, 99-121.
  • 신동일(Shin, D.). 2018. 영어시험에 관한 담론 정치의 역사성 분석: 신자유주의와 평가국가의 논점에서부터(Analyzing historical flow of discourse politics on English language testing in Korea: An overview from the neoliberalism and evaluate state)《응용언어학》(Korean Journal of Applied Linguistics) 34-3, 출간 예정 원고.
  • 신동일⋅박수현⋅김가현⋅조은혜⋅심우진(Shin, D., S. Park, Kim, K. Kim, E. Cho and W. Shim). 2017. 『접촉의 언어학: 다중언어사회의 교육과 정책』(Study of Language Contact: Language Education and Policies in Multilingual Society) 커뮤니케이션북스.
  • 심세광(Shim, S.). 2011. 푸코에게 주체란 무엇인가? 실천이론으로서 푸코의 주체이론의 변모 (What is Subject to Foucault?)《문화과학》(Culture Science) 65, 89-125.
  • 심세광⋅전혜리⋅조성은(Shim, S., H. Song and J. Choi). (공역). 2011. 『안전, 영토, 인구: 콜레주드프랑스 강의』 1977년~78년』(M. Foucault의 Sécurité, territoire, population : cours au Collège de France 1977-1978). 서울: 난장.
  • 심세광⋅전혜리⋅조성은(Shim, S., H. Song and J. Choi). (공역). 2012. 『생명관리정치의 탄생: 콜레주드프랑스 강의 1978~79년』(M. Foucault의 Naissance de la biopolitique). 서울: 난장.
  • 오생근(Oh, S.-K.). (역). 2003. 『감시와 처벌: 감옥의 탄생』(M. Foucault의 Surveiller et punir). 서울: 난장.
  • 이정우(Lee, J.-W.). (역). 1992. 『지식의 고고학』(M. Foucault의 L' arche´ologie du savoir). 서울: 민음사.
  • 이종구⋅천만봉(Lee, J.-G. and M.-B. Cheon). 2013. 한국 대기업 인재상 전개과정과 시대별 특성 비교분석에 관한 탐색적 연구: 1980년대 이후 삼성, 현대, LG, SK를 중심으로(The exploratory study on the comparative analysis of the historical development process on right people and characteristics by the period of Korea major enterprise: Focus on Samsung ⁃ Hyundai ⁃ LG ⁃ SK after the 1980s). 《경영사학》(The Review of Business History) 28-2, 49-78.
  • 하연섭(Ha, Y.-S.). 2003. 정책아이디어와 제도 변화: 우리나라에서 신자유주의의 해석과 적용을 중심으로(Policy idea and institutional change: Translating neoliberalism in Korea). 《행정논총》(Korean Journal of Policy Studies) 44-4, 1-27.
  • 홍성민(Hong, S.-M.). (역). 1991. 『권력과 지식: 미셸 푸코와의 대담』(M. Foucault의 Power/knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972-1977). 서울: 나남.
  • 홍성현⋅류웅재(Hong, S.-H. and W. Ryoo). 2013. 무한 경쟁 시대의 글로벌 인재 되기: 글로벌 인재 담론에 대한 비판적 담론분석(Becoming a global talent in the era of unlimited global competition: A critical discourse analysis of the global talent). 《커뮤니케이션 이론》(Communication Theories) 9-4, 4-57.
  • Bernstein, K. A., E. A. Hellmich, N. Katznelson, J. Shin, and K. Vinall. 2015. Critical perspectives on neoliberalism in second/foreign language education. L2 Journal 7(3), 3-14.
  • Block, D. 2002. McCommunication: A problem in the frame of SLA. In D. Block and D. Cameron, eds., Globalization and Language Teaching, 117-133. London, UK: Routledge. 117-133.
  • Cameron, D. 2000. Good to Talk? Living and Working in a Communication Culture. London: Sage.
  • Canagarajah, S. 2017. Translingual Practics and Neoliberal Policies: Attitudes and Strategies of African Skilled Migrants in Anglophone Workplaces. Berlin: Springer. [https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-41243-6]
  • Dean, M. 2010. Governmentality: Power and Rule in Modern Society (2nd ed.). London: Sage.
  • Gaap, R. 2016. Academic perceptions of higher education assessment processes in neoliberal academia. Critical Studies in Education 57-2, 175-190.
  • Giannone, D. 2016. Neoliberalization by evaluation: Explaining the making of neoliberal evaluative state. PACO 9-2, 495-516.
  • Jankowski, N. and S. Provezis. 2014. Neoliberal ideologies, governmentality and the academy: An examination of accountability through assessment and transparency. Educational Philosophy and Theory 46-5, 475-487.
  • O’Neill, A-M. 2016. Assessment-based curriculum: Globalising and enterprising culture, human capital and teacher-technicians in Aotearoa New Zealand. Journal of Educational Policy 31-5, 598-621.
  • Park, J. 2010. Naturalization of competence and the neoliberal subject: Success stories of English language learning in the Korea conservative press. Journal of Linguistics Anthropology 20-1, 22-38. [https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1548-1395.2010.01046.x]
  • Park, J. 2011. The promise of English: Linguistic capital and the neoliberal worker in the South Korean job market. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism 14-4, 443-455.
  • Piller, I. and J. Cho. 2013. Neoliberalism as language policy. Language in Society 42-1, 23-44.
  • Raaper, R. 2016. Academic perceptions of higher education assessment processes in neoliberal academia. Critical Studies in Education, 57-2, 175-190.
  • Rose, N. 1989. Governing the Soul: The Shaping of the Private Self. Free Association Books.
  • Rose, N. 1998. Inventing Our Selves: Psychology, Power, and Personhood. Cambridge University Press.
  • Shin, H. and J. S. Park. 2016. Researching language and neoliberalism. Journal of Multilingual and Multilingual Development 37-5, 443-452.